Responsible valuation and quality assurance of open access publications via bibliometric indicators (INDIOA)

Start of the project: 2021-Aug-01 - End of the project: 2023-Jul-31

Given the current importance of Open Access (OA) in science policy, the project aims at an informed use of bibliometric metrics in the evaluation of primary OA publication venues in scientific practice.

The collaborative project with SUB Göttingen combines bibliometric studies with awareness activities to promote a responsible approach to novel OA publishing practices at universities and non-university scientific institutions. The goal is to inform about unintended consequences of the use of bibliometric metrics when choosing a venue to publish. In this way, the willingness of scientific authors to take up innovative and quality-assured OA publication offers from small and medium-sized publishers should be strengthened.

The DZHW subproject will focus in particular on the characteristics of OA journals from small and medium-sized publishers. Bibliometric and publishing indicators will be collected in order to investigate the ostensible indexability of the journals in bibliometric databases. In addition, operational processes of quality assurance will be investigated by means of qualitative case studies of individual OA journals in order to derive recommendations for action. The results will be incorporated into the support measures within the awareness activities of the INDIOA project.

Show more Show less
Publications

Assessing bibliodiversity through reference lists: A text analysis approach.

Cruz Romero, R., Stephen, D., & Stahlschmidt, S. (2024).
Assessing bibliodiversity through reference lists: A text analysis approach. In STI2024 (Hrsg.), Proceedings of the 28th International Conference on Science, Technology and Innovation Indicators (STI2024) (S. 1-14). Berlin: STI2024. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.14045592
Abstract

The presence or absence of publishers in large bibliographic databases highlights tangible and symbolic differences between small and large publishers, underlining their diverging incentive structures. To assess these differences, this contribution explores reference data from small (open access) publishers and their journals in the Web of Science and Scopus. The analysis focuses on references that are not indexed in these databases and examines them from a text-as-data approach. The study frames two dimensions of relevance - visibility and impact - as proxies for assessing the scholarly bibliodiversity represented by small (open access) publishers.

Herausgeberschaft und Verantwortung: Über die Un-/Abhängigkeit wissenschaftlicher Fachzeitschriften.

Knöchelmann, M. (2023).
Herausgeberschaft und Verantwortung: Über die Un-/Abhängigkeit wissenschaftlicher Fachzeitschriften. Bibliothek Forschung und Praxis (online first). https://doi.org/10.1515/bfp-2022-0090
Presentations

Assessing Bibliodiversity through Reference Lists: A Text Analysis Approach.

Cruz Romero, R., Stephen, D., & Stahlschmidt, S. (2024, September).
Assessing Bibliodiversity through Reference Lists: A Text Analysis Approach. Vortrag auf der Konferenz 28th International Conference on Science, Technology and Innovation Indicators 2024 (STI), Berlin.

Non-Indexed References in Small Open Access Journals: A Hidden Scientific Discourse?

Cruz Romero, R., & Stahlschmidt, S. (2023, Juli).
Non-Indexed References in Small Open Access Journals: A Hidden Scientific Discourse? Poster auf der Konferenz ISSI 2023, International Society for Informetrics and Scientometrics (ISSI), Indiana University, Bloomington, Indiana, USA.
Abstract

This poster shows specific bibliometric data highlighting differences and similarities between journals’ references indexed in the Web of Science (WoS) and Scopus and those that are not. Specifically, this contribution looks at small publishers and their respective journals along the open/closed access formats. The goal is to problematize and assess the visibility and meaning of literature being cited in indexed journals against the literature not listed in these databases. This can shed light into the scientific practices and narratives of different academic disciplines that are defined more nationally or internationally.

Open Access Small Publishers - indi:oa Preliminary Presentation.

Cruz Romero, R. (2022, Oktober).
Open Access Small Publishers - indi:oa Preliminary Presentation. Vortrag im Rahmen des internen Kolloquiums DZHW, DZHW, Berlin.

" What's in a number? " - Die Bedeutung bibliometrischer Indikatoren als Bewertungsgrundlage von OA-Publikationsangeboten.

Cruz Romero, R. (2022, August).
"What's in a number?" - Die Bedeutung bibliometrischer Indikatoren als Bewertungsgrundlage von OA-Publikationsangeboten. Vortrag im Rahmen der Open Access Talks, open-access.network.

Contact person

Stephan Stahlschmidt
Dr. Stephan Stahlschmidt +49 30 2064177-18

Researchers

Clemens Blümel Roberto Cruz Romero

External Contact

Najko Jahn

In cooperation with

Niedersächsische Staats- und Universitätsbibliothek Göttingen

Funded by

Bundesministerium für Bildung und Forschung